I recently was talking with one prospective client. “One of my board members who has worked with lots of lawyers advised that I be careful. If you consider hiring a former in-house lawyer, make sure she will be responsive to your needs.” Too often, that Board member’s experience has been that former attorneys are slow. He had a tortoise for a lawyer. That experience is not uncommon, unfortunately.
When I became the leader of a part of an in-house team, the
first thing I did was to travel to meet with many of the subgroups of the
business that our group’s internal customers (not clients, because the business
as a whole was our only client). During
those meetings, a theme emerged that some of our legal team’s responses were
not very timely. The responses were
simply taking too long.
Once I heard from a new in-house lawyer that he had
received some advice from a more senior colleague about reviewing contracts for
a business unit. It went something like
this. “Send them back a bunch of
questions by email.” What would that
achieve? Sure, there are legitimate
questions lawyers have to ask to refine a contract. But this senior lawyer was teaching the junior lawyer
how to push something off, and that behavior was reflected in the feedback from
our internal customers.
What are the risks of being the tortoise? First, it slows the business down and
contributes to the feeling that the lawyer is the reason the deal can’t get
done. Second, if the delay is long
enough, the business may be lost. Third,
it does not create the feeling that the lawyers are partners with the business,
which may deter the businesspeople from seeking legal counsel when they should.
It is not enough to provide quality legal advice. That advice must be timely.